Our Dr.’s Most Interesting Cases: the Heel that wouldn’t Heal!

Dr Syndey Yau, Univeristy Foot and Ankle Institute

Dr. Syndey Yau

An most interesting case of mine involves a 69 year-old male who came to me four months after shattering his heel bone (or calcaneus).  He was trimming branches on a ladder about 6 feet high when he fell and landed right on his heel bone.  He went to urgent care, where x-rays were taken, revealing no obvious fracture.  He then went on to see another foot specialist, who diagnosed him with a heel fracture, and treated his injury conservatively with immobilization in a walking cast boot.

After four months of immobilization, he was sent for a CT scan, which revealed a shattered heel bone within the joint, and by then it had healed in a poor position.  It was decided to order a bone stimulator for the patient to help this fracture heel.

At this point the patient came to me at UFAI for a second opinion. By now he was terribly discouraged and wondered why it would take so long for his fracture to heal.  Plus he was having a lot of pain when he walked, even in the walking cast boot.

Now clinically, the patient had no pain when I squeezed his heel bone, but the bone was in an inverted, or varus position.  He had pain along the tendons that run along the outside of the heel, stiffness and pain along the subtalar joint as well (the joint just below the ankle).

I decided to start from ground zero and ordered a set of x-rays, which we took in our office, which revealed obvious arthritis in his subtalar joint, a s well as malalignment of the heel bone in a varus position.

After listening to his story , doing my examination and reading his  radiographs (aka x-rays) it was clear that he had initially suffered a bad injury that was not properly treated from the beginning. Now he had two bad issues that was causing him continued pain and swelling: a malunion of his heal and post-traumatic arthritis.  A bone stimulator, which his prior doctor ordered, was never going to resolve this issue.

About his Malunion

Calcaneal fracture,

Fracture of the heel.

In the time before he came to see me his heel fracture had healed but unfortunately in a bad position, changing his gait and putting more pressure on the outside of his foot and ankle.  Neglected or poorly treated heel fractures will typically heel mal-aligned, in a varus or inverted position, leading to increased stress on the outside of the extremity.

Additionally, due to the compressive nature of the fracture there was a loss of height, or flattening of the heel.  Left untreated this can lead to limb length discrepancies and subsequent compensatory issues if not properly treated.

About his post-traumatic arthritis

Due to the intraarticular nature of the fracture – meaning that the fracture violated the joint – there were now signs of arthritis in the joint.  Heel fractures that violate the joint – the subtalar joint in this case – have a high risk of subsequent arthritis.  If properly reduced, the risk is lessened, but there is still a chance of arthritis.  In this patient’s case, his displaced fracture within the joint that was not originally reduced back into its anatomical alignment.  Due to this, arthritis began developing in the subtalar joint which was due to the mal-alignment of the joint.

How we treated this condition

The surgical plan to correct this patient’s malunion was to make a wedge cut in the heel bone to reduce the varus deformity in the heel.  This would make the heel more neutral and reduce the amount of stress he is putting on the outside of his heel.  I would then attempt to fuse the subtalar joint, adding a bone graft in that joint to recreate some height to the heel.  During the surgery, I would also remove any bone spurs, and inspect for any tendon damage to the outside tendons of the foot (peroneal tendons).   The goal of the surgery was to provide a functional and stable foot for the patient to walk on.  The patient agreed to proceed with this course of treatment.


After surgery, the patient was immobilized in a cast for 2 months, and then placed in a walking boot for 1 month, after seeing evidence of bone fusion of the subtalar joint, and bone cut.  Physical therapy was performed for a couple of months afterwards.

Currently the patient is doing very well.  He is walking without any pain or and the swelling he was experiencing before he came to see me was totally gone.   He is very happy with the surgery and has ended up with a perfectly functional foot which pleases both him me tremendously!

Dr. Yau is available for consultation at our Valencia office. Please call (877) 989-9110 or visit us at www.footankleinstitute.com for more information.

Dr. Sydney K. Yau

Dr. Sydney K. Yau

Dr. Yau received his initial medical training at Temple University in Philadelphia where he specialized in diabetic limb salvage, sports medicine, foot and ankle reconstruction and trauma.

He then went on to complete his surgical reconstruction fellowship with the University Foot and Ankle Institute, one of only a few fellowships recognized by the American College Foot and Ankle Surgeons.

Now playing an integral role at the University Foot and Ankle Institute, Dr. Yau’s treats various sports injuries, including sprains, arthritis and fractures. He also is passionate about helping diabetic patients avoid amputation through correction of deformities and wound healing.

Dr. Yau is available for consultation at our Simi Valley location.
Dr. Sydney K. Yau


  1. Vic mastrogiovanni

    8 years ago I fell off the roof, and shattered both heels. Surgery was done only on the right one. MERSA developed, and all hardware was removed, and I now have bilateral pain in ankle joints and heels. The right is by far the worst. It feels as though my right leg is longer than the other, and I have developed pain in my lower right spine. I don’t know if it’s related to over-compensation or not, since my vertebrae in that area was also fractured, and surgically repaired from the fall. I’ve been told that the only treatment left is fusion, but that will not relieve the heel pain, nor correct my back pain. I will be 70 years old next year, and after all of the complications I’ve endured after 3 surgeries on my heel, I despise the thought of going through any more. I have been on opiates for all these years, and an stuck between a rock and a hard place. What would be your recommendation as far as treatment for a person my age?

    • Dear Vic,

      We are all so sorry to read your post, that is not a good place to be in. And on top of everything else, you got MERSA, that is terrible. We hope you have fully recovered from that at the very least.

      Unfortunately, we cannot give advice via blog, chat or email. Each case is really different and a full history, medical record and films/MRI review would need to be done to even begin to discuss your case. 🙁

      We do offer a virtual consultation service, though it is almost never covered by insurance, which can make it hard for some people. Of course we can see you in person, but to travel to where we are is also not something that is possible for everybody, which is why we offer the virtual consultation service.

      I personally hope you can find someone close to you who you can trust and can give you some honest and straightforward options to improving your situation. If you want to let me know where you are located, I can ask if we know anyone remotely close to you. We usually don’t, but sometimes, depending on where you are, one of our doctors may know someone who is a quality physician. I would be more than happy to ask everyone if you want.

      I thank you for visiting us and truly wish you all the very best.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


eight + 8 =

  • Yelp
    My wife and I went to play tennis on a Wednesday morning, and within 10 minutes, I experienced the most excruciating pain in my right ankle!! Yes, I had TORN the achilles tendon!! OUCH! I hobbled to the car and call...
    Duane D.
  • CustomerSure
    Doctor Franson and the whole staff have been awesome every step of the way! I recommend them to all my family, friends and co-workers every chance I get! Thanks Dr. Franson and UFAI staff!!!!
    Robert B.
  • Yelp
    I had my first experience with this office earlier this week. Dr. Franson spent ample time with me, and was very attentive to my concerns and questions. I especially appreciated his relaxed, but thorough, way of deali...
    Chuck S.
  • ZocDoc
    Professional, to the point, pleasant. Very happy with the service and the ability to schedule via ZocDoc.
    Deborah F.
  • CustomerSure
    You all are very good at your job. So glad I am going here.
    Gary D.
  • ZocDoc
    Was very impressed with the professionalism of the entire office. Very courteous and knowledgeable nurses - prompt and gentle too.
    Ronald B.
  • Yelp
    I love Dr Bob! I am a runner and my feet were hurting so badly that I wanted to stop doing the activity that I loved.  I went to him reluctantly on a recommendation from a friend and his friendly office staff brought ...
  • CustomerSure
    The therapists are very knowledgeable. It was nice to see how they all helped out where needed. If someone started something, but was busy when a treatment ended, then someone else would finish up. A nice team effort.
    Hunter M.
  • Yelp
    My 1st time visiting University Foot & Ankle was a great experience! Dr. Yau was very helpful and even provided his email to contact him about any concerns I may have had due to my injury. Awesome staff and great loca...
    Juan A.
  • CustomerSure
    Exceptional care! The therapist really pays you personal attention. Something I especially liked was being asked my expectations for physical therapy at the onset of the treatment.
    Benji M.
Same day appointments now available!
or call us:
  • University Foot & Ankle, a Preferred Provider to:
  • UCLA Health System - UCLA Medical Group
  • MPTF - Member Industry Health Network
  • Cirque du Soleil
  • ATP - Association of Tennis Professionals
  • And consulting physicians for:
  • C&S - Cedars-Sinai
  • Saint John's Health Center